.jpeg)
Elon Musk reached an agreement to buy Twitter for roughly $44 billion on
Monday, promising a more lenient touch to policing content on the social
media platform where he — the world’s richest person — promotes his
interests, attacks critics and opines on a wide range of issues to more than
83 million followers.
The outspoken Tesla CEO has said he wanted to own and privatize Twitter
because he thinks it’s not living up to its potential as a platform for free
speech.
Musk said in a joint statement with Twitter that he wants to make the
service “better than ever” with new features, such as getting rid of
automated “spam″ accounts and making its algorithms open to the public to
increase trust.
“Free speech is the bedrock of a functioning democracy, and Twitter is the
digital town square where matters vital to the future of humanity are
debated,” the 50-year-old Musk said, adding hearts, stars and rocket emojis
in a tweet that highlighted the statement.
The more hands-off approach to content moderation that Musk envisions has
many users concerned that the platform will become more of a haven for
disinformation, hate speech and bullying, something it has worked hard in
recent years to mitigate. Wall Street analysts said if he goes too far, it
could also alienate advertisers.
The deal was cemented roughly two weeks after the billionaire first revealed
a 9% stake in the platform. Musk said last week that he had lined up $46.5
billion in financing to buy Twitter, putting pressure on the company’s board
to negotiate a deal.
Twitter said the transaction was unanimously approved by its board of
directors and is expected to close in 2022, pending regulatory sign-off and
the approval of shareholders.
Shares of Twitter Inc. rose more than 5% Monday to $51.70 per share. On
April 14, Musk announced an offer to buy Twitter for $54.20 per share. While
the stock is up sharply since Musk made his offer, it is well below the high
of $77 per share it reached in February 2021.
Musk has described himself as a “free-speech absolutist” but is also known
for blocking or disparaging other Twitter users who question or disagree
with him.
In recent weeks, he has voiced a number of proposed changes for the company,
from relaxing its content restrictions — such as the rules that suspended
former President Donald Trump’s account — to ridding the platform of fake
and automated accounts, and shifting away from its advertising-based revenue
model. Musk believes he can increase revenue through subscriptions that give
paying customers a better experience, perhaps even an ad-free version of
Twitter.
As Twitter’s main customers, advertisers have also been a voice in pushing
for stronger content rules that Musk has criticized. Asked during a recent
TED talk if there are any limits to his notion of “free speech,” Musk said
Twitter or any forum is “obviously bound by the laws of the country that it
operates in. So obviously there are some limitations on free speech in the
US, and, of course, Twitter would have to abide by those rules.”
Beyond that, though, he said he’d be “very reluctant” to delete things and
in general be cautious about permanently banning users who violate the
company’s rules.
It won’t be perfect, Musk added, “but I think we want it to really have the
perception and reality that speech is as free as reasonably possible.”
After the deal was announced, the NAACP released a statement that urged Musk
not to allow former President Trump, the 45th president, back onto the
platform.
“Disinformation, misinformation and hate speech have NO PLACE on Twitter,”
the civil rights organization said in a statement. “Do not allow 45 to
return to the platform. Do not allow Twitter to become a petri dish for hate
speech, or falsehoods that subvert our democracy.”
During his candidacy and presidency, Trump used Twitter as a powerful
megaphone that enabled him to speak to the public directly, often using
incendiary and divisive language on hot-button issues. He was permanently
banned from the service in the aftermath of the Jan. 6 storming of the
Capitol.
Efforts to “deregulate” Twitter could thwart the company’s current
commitment to making the platform as safe as possible for all users, said
Brooke Erin Duffy, professor of communication at Cornell University and an
expert on social media. ”
“Marginalized communities of users are especially vulnerable to the forms of
hate and harassment that so often circulate in unregulated online spaces,”
she said.
Forrester Research director Mike Proulx said that if Musk decides to loosen
content moderation policies, he puts Twitter ad dollars at risk. “Brands are
becoming more conscious of their adjacency to risky content or
disinformation, so they may take their dollars to other channels with
greater safety measures in place,” he said.
Some users said Monday that they were planning to quit the platform if Musk
took it over. To which he responded on Twitter: “I hope that even my worst
critics remain on Twitter, because that is what free speech means.”
Musk has battled with the Securities and Exchange Commission on multiple
occasions, as he has used Twitter to taunt the regulators.
The SEC has been investigating Musk’s August 2018 tweets in which he
asserted that he’d secured funding to take Tesla private for $420 a share,
though he had not. Musk is fighting an SEC subpoena in the case in federal
court. More recently, Musk appeared to have violated SEC rules by failing to
disclose at the point he reached a 5% stake in Twitter, waiting until he had
more than 9%.
Noteworthy as they are, the SEC matters have no bearing on Musk’s fitness to
buy a company, according to St. John’s University business professor Anthony
Sabino, making it unlikely that they would represent roadblocks to the
takeover.
With initial concerns of its own about the deal, Twitter had enacted an
anti-takeover measure known as a poison pill that could make a takeover
attempt prohibitively expensive. But the board decided to negotiate after
Musk updated his proposal last week to show he had secured financing,
according to The Wall Street Journal.
While Twitter’s user base of more than 200 million remains much smaller than
those of rivals such as Facebook and TikTok, the service is popular with
celebrities, world leaders, journalists and intellectuals. Musk himself is a
prolific tweeter with a following that rivals several pop stars in the ranks
of the most popular accounts.
Last week, he said in documents filed with U.S. securities regulators that
the money would come from Morgan Stanley and other banks, some of it secured
by his huge stake in Tesla.
Musk is the world’s wealthiest person, according to Forbes, with a nearly
$279 billion fortune. But much of his money is tied up in Tesla stock — he
owns about 17% of the electric car company, according to FactSet, which is
valued at more than $1 trillion — and SpaceX, his privately held space
company. It’s unclear how much cash Musk has.
Musk began making his fortune in 1999 when he sold Zip2, an online mapping
and business directory, to Compaq for $307 million. He used his share to
create what would become PayPal, an internet service that bypassed banks and
allowed consumers to pay businesses directly. It was sold to eBay for $1.5
billion in 2002.
That same year, Musk founded Space Exploration Technologies, or SpaceX,
after finding that cost constraints were limiting NASA’s interplanetary
travel. The company eventually developed cost-effective reusable rockets.
In 2004, Musk was courted to invest in Tesla, then a startup trying to build
an electric car. Eventually he became CEO and led the company to
astronomical success as the world’s most valuable automaker and largest
seller of electric vehicles.
Musk’s pledge to make Twitter a haven for free speech could dim the appeal
of Donald Trump’s troubled Truth Social app, which the former president has
touted as a competitor to Twitter that would cater to conservatives. Truth
Social is part of Trump’s new media company, which has agreed to be taken
public by Digital World Acquisition Corp. Shares of DWAC dropped 16.2%
Monday and are down 46% since Musk revealed his stake in Twitter.